QQ客服 官方微博 反馈留言

	对象即方法:法官事实认定的心理学分析——对苏力“黄碟案”演讲的再思考; Object as Method: Rethinking of the Psychology Analysis in Judge's Fact Finding from Professor Zhu Suli's Speech on “The Case of Pornographic Videodisc”
	陆而启
	2014-04-25
关键词	普遍联系 假想敌 命题预设 对象即方法 法律事实 Universal relation Putative foe Default proposition Object as method Legal fact
英文摘要	语境论、“具体问题具体分析“或者理论联系实际等论证方法的过度运用令人生疑。一是在把握事实方面,自己树立一个假想的靶子进行批判,而三段论的演绎推理或者分析,或因假设前提错误,或因不存在因果关联,而导致结果不能证;二是教条的、无原则的具体分析,借题发挥的普遍联系,因为多走了一步,真理就转化成了谬误。为方法而方法、为批判而批判可能是一种舍本逐末的研究思路。而“对象即方法“的研究思路可能是法官事实认定的心理学分析的一个基本前提。; It is suspicious to over emphasize the importance of certain reasoning methods such as context theory,concrete analyses on specifi c issues,or applying theories to real-life situations.On one hand,in terms of grasping the fact,an imaginary target set up by oneself for criticism will lead to the improvable result because of error or inexistence of assumptions or because of no causal relationship in the syllogism analysis or deductive reasoning; On the other hand,due to dogmatic,unreasonable concrete analysis and extremely widespread digression from the universal relation,it simply goes too far,which leads the truth being converted into fallacy.Method for method and criticism for criticism tends to become a research approach merely for formality.The research approach of emphasizing "object as method" is likely to be a fundamental prerequisite for psychological analysis in judge's fact-fi ndings.
语种	zh_CN
内容类型	期刊论文
源URL	[http://dspace.xmu.edu.cn/handle/2288/100241]
专题	法学院－已发表论文
推荐引用方式 GB/T 7714	陆而启. 对象即方法:法官事实认定的心理学分析——对苏力“黄碟案”演讲的再思考, Object as Method: Rethinking of the Psychology Analysis in Judge's Fact Finding from Professor Zhu Suli's Speech on “The Case of Pornographic Videodisc”[J],2014.
APA	陆而启.(2014).对象即方法:法官事实认定的心理学分析——对苏力“黄碟案”演讲的再思考..
MLA	陆而启."对象即方法:法官事实认定的心理学分析——对苏力“黄碟案”演讲的再思考".(2014).

个性服务

查看访问统计

相关权益政策

暂无数据

收藏/分享

除非特别说明，本系统中所有内容都受版权保护，并保留所有权利。